J & S New York Pizza

Nestled in the heart of Fuquay-Varina, J & S New York Pizza serves up an authentic slice of Italian-American comfort with a distinct New York flair. This local favorite brings together the best of pizza artistry and classic Italian dishes, all crafted to delight the senses and satisfy real cravings.

Whether you're craving the iconic rich and cheesy New York Style Cheese Pizza or yearn for something more indulgently stuffed like their signature 16 Stuffed Pizza, J & S offers a menu bursting with flavor and variety. Their Rice Balls and Traditional Ham Calzone provide a comforting depth of taste, while options like the Meat Lovers Pizza and the inventive Pepperoni, Banana Peppers & Mushroom Pizza showcase their talent for bold, perfectly balanced flavor combinations.

Beyond pizza, the restaurant shines with dishes such as FM Spaghetti with Meatballs Special and FM Chicken Parmigiana with Pasta — classics done with heart and attention to authentic Italian-American tradition. For a starter or side, the Mozzarella Caprese and Burrata Salad add fresh, vibrant layers of flavor, while the daily Soup of the Day and creamy Clam Chowder offer warming satisfaction. Wings lovers are well cared for too, with Garlic Parmesan and Buffalo Chicken Wings that aim to hit the perfect note between crispy and saucy.

J & S’s appeal extends beyond just the food. Diners frequently celebrate the inviting atmosphere, including their popular patio seating that perfectly complements leisurely meals. Customers rave about the friendly, accommodating staff and a comfortable environment that feels like a true neighborhood gem.

In addition to dine-in, their meal delivery service impresses with quick preparation times and fresh, warm pizzas that travel well, even for those ordering from a distance. Reviews highlight the consistently excellent cheese steaks and wings, with glowing mentions of the gluten-free pizza option—an important touch for those with dietary preferences.

While most dishes captivate the palate with rich textures and bold flavors—impressively hitting the mark on classic NY-style authenticity—some guests note occasional room for improvement, such as more robust seasoning on garlic bread. Nevertheless, the overall experience at J & S remains a standout for lovers of hearty, soulful Italian food with a genuine New York spirit.

Whether you’re stopping by for the Legendary Sampler filled with Fried Mushrooms, Mozzarella Sticks, and Boneless Chicken Wings, or gathering friends for an unbeatable XL Pie feast complete with wings and soda, J & S New York Pizza delights as a vibrant hub for great food, friendly faces, and that unmistakable taste of New York right in Fuquay-Varina.